avatar
Henry Glickel
603-770-7175 | Schedule time with me

Chapter 2: Uncovering Potential: When Overlooked Candidates Become Top Performers



Chapter 2

Uncovering Potential:
When Overlooked Candidates Become Top Performers

One of the biggest mistakes in sales recruiting is assuming that the best candidate is always the person with the strongest résumé. Experience matters. Industry knowledge matters. A candidate’s track record matters. But those things do not tell the entire story.

Sometimes the person who looks less impressive on paper has the qualities that matter most once they get into the role. Grit. Coachability. Resilience. Intrinsic motivation. The willingness to learn and keep going when the first few weeks, months, or deals do not go as planned.

These qualities can be difficult to identify because they do not always appear on a résumé. They may not show up in a job title or years-of-experience requirement. Sometimes they become visible only when someone is given an opportunity. I have seen this firsthand.

 

The Candidate Everyone Else Overlooked

A former employee had previously supported the sales research function at the company. She left on good terms and eventually expressed interest in returning. This time, she applied for a BDR position. The team she applied to was struggling, and the hiring manager dismissed her almost immediately after the interview. On the surface, there did not appear to be much reason to reconsider the decision.

After the interview, however, she reconnected with former colleagues and eventually met with me. As we talked about her career, I saw something that had not been apparent from the initial evaluation. She had grit. She was determined. She was motivated. She wanted the opportunity to prove herself. More importantly, these qualities appeared to come from within. She did not need someone else to create her motivation for her.

I advocated for her hiring. A few weeks later, she joined my team. Not long after that, she became the top-performing BDR in the company. That experience reinforced an important lesson for me: “Sometimes the candidate who is overlooked is not the candidate who lacks potential. The candidate may simply be the person whose potential has not yet been recognized.”Experience Is Not the Whole Story

Recruiters and hiring managers naturally look for experience because experience provides evidence. If someone has sold a similar product, worked with similar customers, and consistently achieved a sales target, there is a logical reason to consider that person. But experience has limits.

A candidate can have years of experience and still struggle with rejection, feedback, change, or accountability. Another candidate may have less direct experience but possess the resilience and motivation required to learn quickly and persist through difficult situations. This is particularly important in sales.

Salespeople hear "no" regularly. They lose deals. They miss targets. They have difficult conversations with prospects. They receive coaching from managers. They encounter changes in products, territories, pricing, competition, and customer expectations. The question is not whether a salesperson will experience setbacks. The question is what the salesperson does after the setback. That is where grit and resilience become important.

 

Hire for Grit

Grit is the ability to continue working toward an objective when the path becomes difficult. In sales, that quality matters. A salesperson can have a strong résumé and still become discouraged after a series of rejected calls. Another salesperson may experience the same rejection and use it as information, adjust the approach, and make the next call. That difference can have a significant impact over time.

The source material for this chapter emphasizes that many hiring failures are related to attitudinal factors such as coachability, grit, and motivation rather than a simple lack of technical skills. It also emphasizes that skills can be developed, while perseverance and intrinsic drive can be much harder to create through training. This does not mean skills are unimportant. It means recruiters should understand which skills can reasonably be taught and which characteristics are more difficult to develop after someone is hired.

Consider two candidates. Candidate A has five years of relevant sales experience but becomes defensive whenever a manager provides feedback. Candidate B has two years of sales experience but actively asks for feedback, acknowledges mistakes, and explains what they changed after receiving coaching. Which candidate has the stronger foundation for development? The answer may not be obvious from the résumé. That is why the interview has to go deeper.Look for the Response to Failure

One of the most useful ways to identify grit is to ask candidates about difficult experiences. Do not simply ask: "Tell me about a challenge." That question is too broad. Instead, ask candidates to explain what happened, what they did, what went wrong, what they learned, and what they did differently afterward.

Questions such as these can reveal much more:

  • Tell me about a sales opportunity you lost that you expected to win. What happened?
  • Describe a time when you missed an important goal. What did you do next?
  • Tell me about a time you received difficult feedback from a manager.
  • What is something you struggled with early in your sales career?
  • What did you change after discovering that your original approach was not working?
  • Tell me about a time you had to continue pursuing a goal after experiencing repeated setbacks.

The objective is not to find a candidate who has never failed. That candidate probably does not exist. The objective is to understand how the candidate responds when things do not go according to plan.

 

Coachability Separates Potential from Performance

Grit is only part of the equation. A salesperson can be highly motivated and still struggle if they are unwilling to learn. That is where coachability becomes critical. Sales professionals develop over time. They make mistakes, receive feedback, adjust their behavior, and try again.

A coachable person does not have to agree with every piece of feedback. But they should be willing to listen, understand the manager's perspective, consider the evidence, and determine what can be improved.

The source material describes coaching as an important part of sales development because becoming successful is a progression rather than an instant result. It also points out that constructive criticism can be uncomfortable, making the candidate's response to feedback particularly revealing. This gives recruiters another area to investigate.

Ask: "Tell me about a piece of feedback you received that was difficult to hear."

Then follow up.

  • What did you initially think about the feedback?
  • What did you do with it?
  • Did you change anything?
  • What happened afterward?

A candidate who can describe a real example of receiving difficult feedback, applying it, and improving provides evidence of coachability. That is much more useful than simply asking, Are you coachable? Most candidates will say yes. The story tells you more than the answer.

 

Intrinsic Motivation Matters

Another quality worth examining is intrinsic motivation. What actually drives the candidate? Money may be important. Career advancement may be important. Recognition may be important. There is nothing wrong with any of these motivations.

  • But recruiters should also try to understand what happens when external rewards are not immediately available.
  • What keeps the candidate moving forward?
  • What makes them pursue a difficult objective?
  • What causes them to keep learning when nobody is forcing them to?

The source material recommends exploring the candidate's internal desires and sense of urgency. It also notes that genuine interest in the product can be helpful, but it is not necessarily the primary motivation for every successful salesperson. That distinction matters.

A candidate does not have to be passionate about every product they sell. They do need to understand what motivates them and demonstrate that they can sustain effort when the work becomes difficult.

 

Do Not Confuse a Weak First Impression With Low Potential

One of the easiest ways to miss talent is to make a decision too quickly. A candidate may interview poorly. They may be nervous. They may not know how to present their accomplishments. They may lack experience with your particular interview process.

They may not have the exact background you originally requested. None of those things automatically mean the person cannot succeed. This is especially important when evaluating candidates who have unconventional career histories.

A résumé can tell you where someone has been. It cannot always tell you where someone can go. That is why recruiters should learn to distinguish between lack of evidence and evidence of lack of ability. Those are not the same thing. If the evidence is incomplete, ask more questions.

 

Hidden Talent Is Often Outside the Traditional Candidate Pool

The idea of overlooked talent extends beyond one candidate or one company. There are people who are unemployed or underemployed. There are caregivers returning to the workforce. There are veterans transitioning into civilian careers. There are people without traditional educational qualifications. There are people whose previous job titles do not accurately reflect the skills they developed.

These candidates can be easy to overlook when hiring processes rely heavily on traditional qualifications. The source material describes these individuals as part of the broader hidden-worker population and emphasizes the risk of missing dedicated and loyal talent by evaluating candidates too narrowly.

This does not mean every nontraditional candidate is automatically a strong candidate. It means the recruiter should investigate the person rather than reject them based solely on an unconventional background.

Ask:

  • What skills did you develop in your previous environment?
  • What responsibilities did you have that may not be obvious from your title?
  • What did you accomplish?
  • What did you have to overcome?
  • What did you learn?
  • Why are you pursuing this opportunity now?

The answers may uncover capabilities that the résumé did not make obvious.

 

Second Chances Can Produce Strong Results

There is another group that recruiters sometimes overlook: people who have already worked for the company. A former employee who left on good terms may return with greater maturity, renewed motivation, and a better understanding of the organization.

Of course, a returning employee should still go through an appropriate evaluation. Past employment should not create an automatic pass. But it should create an opportunity to ask a different set of questions.

  • Why did the person leave?
  • Why do they want to return?
  • What has changed?
  • What did they learn while they were away?
  • What would they do differently this time?

The source material emphasizes that returning employees can bring renewed focus, loyalty, and motivation, particularly when they value the opportunity to prove themselves again.

My experience with the BDR who returned to the company is a good example. She had already been there. Someone had already formed an opinion about her. She could easily have been dismissed because of that earlier perception. Instead, she was given another opportunity, and she became the top-performing BDR in the company. That is the power of a second look.

 

Leadership Can Unlock Potential

Recruiting does not end when the offer is accepted. The environment a person enters can determine how much of their potential actually becomes visible. A strong candidate placed under poor leadership may struggle. An overlooked candidate placed under strong leadership may flourish.

Supportive leaders establish clear expectations, provide feedback, offer mentorship, and create an environment where employees can develop. The source material specifically connects supportive leadership with the ability to bring hidden potential to the surface. This creates an important responsibility for hiring managers.

If you hire someone because you believe they have potential, you have to give that potential an opportunity to develop. You cannot hire for coachability and then refuse to coach. You cannot hire for motivation and then provide no clear goals. You cannot hire someone because you believe they are resilient and then provide no support when they encounter their first major obstacle. Recruiting and leadership are connected.

 

What Should Recruiters Look For?

When evaluating a candidate who may not have the traditional background, I would focus on five areas.

1. Grit - Has the candidate demonstrated perseverance when things became difficult?

2. Coachability - Can the candidate receive feedback without becoming defensive and use that feedback to improve?

3. Intrinsic Motivation - Does the candidate have internal reasons for pursuing goals and continuing through challenges?

4. Adaptability - Can the candidate learn, adjust, and operate effectively when circumstances change?

5. Evidence of Growth - Can the candidate demonstrate that they have improved over time?

These characteristics do not eliminate the need for experience. They help recruiters understand what experience alone cannot tell them.

 

A Better Way to Interview for Potential

If you want to uncover overlooked talent, change the questions. Instead of focusing only on what the candidate has done, explore how they think and respond. Here are several areas to examine:

Past Setbacks - Tell me about a time something did not work. What did you do?

Feedback - Tell me about a time a manager disagreed with your approach. How did you respond?

Learning - What is something you were not good at when you started, but eventually learned?

Persistence - Tell me about a goal you pursued even when progress was slow.

Motivation - What keeps you motivated when you are not seeing immediate results?

Adaptability - Tell me about a time you had to change your approach because the original plan was not working.

Self-awareness - What is a weakness you have actively worked to improve?

The goal is not to create a perfect interview script. The goal is to create enough conversation to see the person behind the résumé.

 

The Recruiter's Role Is to Look Again

Good recruiting is not simply about finding people who meet a list of requirements. It is about understanding what those requirements actually mean. If a client says, "I need someone with five years of experience," the recruiter should understand why. Is the five years required because the person needs specific technical knowledge? Because the sales cycle is complex? Because the person must manage enterprise relationships? Or because the hiring manager believes experience reduces risk?

Those are very different situations. If experience is being used as a proxy for maturity, judgment, resilience, or sales ability, there may be other ways to identify those qualities. That is where the recruiter's judgment becomes valuable. The recruiter can ask the questions the hiring manager may not have considered.

 

The Cost of Overlooking Potential

Every time a company rejects a candidate, it makes a decision about potential. Sometimes that decision is correct. Sometimes it is not. The problem is that companies rarely know which overlooked candidates could have succeeded because they never give them the opportunity. The source material emphasizes that hiring for resilience, perseverance, and intrinsic motivation can help organizations identify hidden talent and reduce costly hiring mistakes.

The lesson is not to hire everyone who shows determination. The lesson is to avoid confusing a traditional résumé with a complete picture of capability. A candidate with less experience may need more training. A candidate returning to the workforce may need time to rebuild confidence. A candidate coming from a different industry may have a learning curve. But if that person has the right foundation, the investment can pay off.

 

Conclusion

The strongest candidate is not always the person with the longest résumé. Sometimes the strongest candidate is the person who has been underestimated. The candidate who lost a job and rebuilt. The employee who left and returned with renewed motivation. The salesperson who struggled early but learned from every mistake.

The applicant who does not have the traditional background but has demonstrated persistence, adaptability, and a willingness to learn. These candidates require a different kind of recruiting. You have to look beyond the obvious. You have to ask better questions.

You have to understand the difference between skills that can be taught and characteristics that are much harder to develop. Most importantly, you have to recognize potential when it appears in an unexpected form.

In the next chapter we’ll explore what really matters in the first 6 -12 months to define success.

Key Takeaways

  1. Do not evaluate candidates solely by résumé experience. Experience provides useful evidence, but it does not reveal every quality required for long-term sales success.
  2. Look for grit and resilience. Sales professionals will experience rejection, missed opportunities, and setbacks. Their response to those experiences matters.
  3. Test for coachability. Ask candidates about feedback they have received and what they did with it.
  4. Understand intrinsic motivation. Find out what keeps candidates moving toward a goal when results are not immediate.
  5. Do not dismiss nontraditional candidates too quickly. Hidden talent may exist among people whose backgrounds do not match conventional hiring profiles.
  6. Give second chances serious consideration. Returning employees can bring renewed motivation, loyalty, and focus when the circumstances are right.
  7. Leadership determines how much potential becomes performance. A strong candidate still needs clear expectations, coaching, mentorship, and the opportunity to develop.
  8. Recruiters should help hiring managers see beyond the obvious. The recruiter's value is not simply delivering candidates. It is helping the organization understand which qualities will actually lead to success.

The next challenge is taking these principles and applying them to the way candidates are evaluated before they ever receive an offer. Finding potential is one thing. Knowing how to recognize it consistently is another.



Previous Page
Blog Search
Category
Authors
Archive

With Over 30 Years of experience we know how to help you

Contact Us